The Change-Up begins with a poop joke. And not just any poop joke — this is projectile poop from a baby girl into her daddy’s mouth during a bleary-eyed, middle-of-the-night diaper change.
You’d think that would be a frightening harbinger of what’s to come over the next two hours, but it’s not — which makes it even more frustrating when you realize that it didn’t need to startle us in such crass and obvious fashion. There was potential here.
When you’ve got Ryan Reynolds and Jason Bateman — two masters of deadpan improvisational comedy — bouncing off each other, you should theoretically just be able to let the cameras roll and follow them wherever they take you. With a screenplay from Jon Lucas and Scott Moore, who wrote The Hangover — the clever, original Hangover, not the lazy sequel — you should already be in pretty good shape.
But the overlong film from David Dobkin (who also directed Wedding Crashers and, unfortunately, Fred Claus) is all over the place in tone, veering awkwardly from some daring comic moments to feel-good sappiness and back again in hopes of redeeming some semblance of edginess. It’s as if The Change-Up is trying to say, “Just kidding! We didn’t mean to be so sappy and square. Well, maybe we did, just a little. Whatever you guys like best.”
Learning lessons is what body-swapping movies are all about. The grass is always greener on the other side until you have to mow it, or something. Here, Bateman plays Dave Lockwood, a wealthy, successful Atlanta lawyer. He’s happily married to Jamie (Leslie Mann), with whom he has a sweet, 5-year-old daughter and a couple of adorable, 2-year-old twins. But he misses spontaneity and fun.
His childhood best friend, Reynolds’ defiantly single Mitch Planko, spends his days doing bong hits in his man cave. Sometimes, he goes out on auditions for commercials. At night, he beds as many random women as possible. But he longs to have someone to come home to, to feel loved and secure.
One night, after too many drinks, Dave and Mitch relieve themselves in a fountain. Each insists the other guy has the better life. When they wake up the next morning, poof! They’ve switched bodies, which leads to some predictable but amusingly executed fish-out-of-water scenarios. Mitch, as Dave, uses sheer bravado to navigate the uptight law firm where Dave is on the verge of making partner. Dave, as Mitch, gets an unexpected booty call late one night from one of Mitch’s wild flings.
As an actor, Bateman gets the better end of the deal here: He’s got Reynolds’ wild child trapped inside of him, so he gets the showier part. Reynolds has a fearlessness with physical comedy but he’s got Bateman’s rigid, conservative character stuck in his body. Except for one scene in which Dave-as-Mitch makes a light porno film (or a “lorno,” as they call it), he doesn’t get as much of an opportunity to let loose.
Olivia Wilde is sexy and charismatic as the law associate Dave secretly lusts after and gets to go on a date with inside Mitch’s body. The Change-Up fleshes out her character and gives her some brains and personality, rather than letting her be eye candy as so many male-dominated comedies might have, which makes you wish the rest of the film had taken the high road. We won’t trouble you with a description of what happens to Mann’s character after too much Thai food.
Cast: Ryan Reynolds, Jason Bateman, Olivia Wilde, Leslie Mann.
Director: David Dobkin.
Screenwriters: Jon Lucas, Scott Moore.
Producers: David Dobkin, Neal H. Moritz.
A Universal Pictures release. Running time: 112 minutes. Pervasive strong, crude sexual content and language, some graphic nudity, drug use. Opens Friday Aug. 5 at area theaters.